But this study points the finger at a particularly troublesome culprit, according to researcher Rebecca Robbins, of the Division of Sleep and Circadian Rhythms at Brigham and Women\’s Hospital in Boston.
\”We looked at a series of sleep characteristics, which allowed us to ask what matters most?\” Robbins said. \”The resounding answer was short sleep.\”
Among these study participants, that mattered more than self-rated sleep quality, or whether it took them a long time to fall asleep at night, or whether they tended to feel groggy or need naps during the day.
Short sleep also appeared more important than snoring, the study found. Chronic snoring is a sign of sleep apnea, which has been linked to both heart disease and dementia.
Still, the findings do not prove short sleep, itself, helps cause dementia or shave years from people\’s lives.
\”It may be that in some cases, the poor sleep is actually an early sign of dementia, rather than a cause,\” said Dr. Sabra Abbott, an assistant professor of neurology in sleep medicine at Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine in Chicago.
Abbott, who wasn\’t involved with the study, said that sleep can be disrupted for multiple reasons early in the dementia process.
As an example, she pointed to a brain structure called the suprachiasmatic nucleus (SN), which helps regulate the timing of sleep and production of the sleep hormone melatonin. The SN can start to degenerate early in the course of dementia.
Robbins also noted that dementia can cause sleep issues, and said she and her colleagues tried to account for that. They excluded older adults who already had dementia at the study\’s outset, and statistically accounted for other health conditions participants had — including heart disease, diabetes, high blood pressure and depression symptoms.
They found that short sleep was still linked to a twofold increase in the risk of dying or developing dementia during the study period.
The results are based on 2,610 Americans age 65 and up who took part in a nationally representative health study. More than half reported getting seven to eight hours of sleep each night. About 4% said they got five hours or fewer.
Over the next five years, 321 study participants screened positive for dementia.
There was no evidence that long sleep — at least nine hours per night — was linked to increased dementia or death risk on its own. Once researchers accounted for chronic health conditions, that appeared to explain any connection.
Robbins said there are reasons to believe that sleep deprivation can do damage to the brain. Animal research shows that adequate sleep may be critical to the brain\’s clearing of abnormal proteins that are associated with Alzheimer\’s disease.
\”There is certainly reason to suspect that poor sleep may worsen dementia in susceptible individuals,\” Abbott said.
But in general, it\’s difficult to know whether poor sleep helps cause the brain disease, or is part of its manifestation, she said.
While that question remains, Robbins said it\’s wise to strive for healthy sleep habits. She had some suggestions:
- Keep TVs and devices out of the bedroom. \”Make the bedroom for sleep, and sleep alone.\”
- Avoid looking at bright screens close to bedtime. That blue light can throw off the body\’s natural circadian rhythm.
- To support that natural rhythm, get plenty of sunshine during the day. \”Fresh air and sunlight are like nature\’s medicine,\” Robbins said. If it\’s not possible to go outside, she noted, even sitting by a window helps.
Abbott agreed that poor sleep should be addressed. But, she added, \”keep in mind that the solution may not be as simple as just trying to get more sleep.\”
She encouraged people with chronic sleep complaints to get a medical evaluation, since there may be an underlying cause that is treatable, like sleep apnea.
The U.S. National Institutes of Health has more on sleep deficiency.
SOURCES: Rebecca Robbins, PhD, research fellow, Division of Sleep and Circadian Rhythms, Brigham and Women\’s Hospital, Boston; Sabra Abbott, MD, PhD, assistant professor, neurology in sleep medicine, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago; Aging, online, Feb. 11, 2021